Battle of the Bands: Doctor My Eyes by Jackson Browne

It’s June 15th and the official kickoff to Battle of the Bands going monthly. From here on out, Battles will be held once a month, on the 15th of every month. (Note: some BOTB participants will still post two battles per month, on the 1st and the 15th).

My mid-month battle is featuring the song Doctor My Eyes by Jackson Browne.

“Doctor My Eyes” is a 1972 song written and performed by Jackson Browne and included on his debut album Jackson Browne. Featuring a combination of an upbeat piano riff coupled, somewhat ironically, with lyric about feeling world-weary, the song was a surprise hit, reaching #8 on the Billboard Hot 100 in spring 1972, after debuting on the chart at #80. In Canada, the song peaked at #4.

Jesse Ed Davis played the electric guitar while David Crosby and Graham Nash sang backing vocals, and Russ Kunkel played drums.

I’ve always loved this song. It’s interesting in that the upbeat music doesn’t match the lyrics. Here’s some history of the song from Wikipedia: William Ruhlmann on Allmusic.com elaborated on the development of the song: “Browne first recorded a demo of ‘Doctor My Eyes’ for the Criterion Music publishing company in early 1971, and despite its striking imagery and carefully crafted writing, it was a bleak song… By the time he came to record the song for his first album in the summer of 1971, however, Browne had revised the lyric, tossing out the most pessimistic lines. Now, ‘Doctor My Eyes’ was the statement of a man who had stoically endured life’s hardships, but having done so, now worried that he had been rendered unable to feel anything. It still wasn’t an optimistic song, but the unhappy ending had been rendered ambiguous.” Ruhlmann addresses the final recorded version’s “paradoxical sense” between the music and the lyrics: “Working with other musicians, Browne drastically altered the sound of the song on record. A lively 4/4 beat, played on drums and congas, and supported by piano, set up a catchy underlying riff before the lyrics even began. Browne’s singing was supported by Graham Nash and David Crosby’s harmonies, giving the lyrics an emotional edge. On the whole, the arrangement and performance worked against the still desperate message contained in the words.” There was originally a third verse to the song, but it was not retained when Browne recorded the song for his debut album. The lost verse, however, can be found on circulating bootlegs of the song’s original demo.

In part 1 of the 2013 documentary History of the Eagles, JD Souther and Glenn Frey discuss at some length the process of Browne’s work methods while Browne was working on the song over a period of some months. The three lived in adjacent downmarket apartments; the future Eagles would hear Browne, through the walls, at work on his piano every morning.

On the song’s reception: Jeff Walker, in his review of Browne’s debut album for Phonograph Record magazine in 1972, wrote that “Doctor My Eyes” is one of a number of tracks on the album that “deal with a spiritual search; no preaching, no conclusions, just searching.”

Ruhlmann on Allmusic called it “a rollicking pop/rock song about being almost terminally burnt out.”

Here’s a terrific live performance of Jackson Browne’s appearance on Rockpalast (Rock Palace), a German music television show, in 1986. Don’t vote for this version: it’s here for your enjoyment only.

 

THE BATTLE, featuring female vocals:

CONTENDER #1: Wilson Phillips 

Wilson Phillips covered the song on their 2004 album “California”.  Wilson Phillips is an American vocal group consisting of Carnie Wilson, Wendy Wilson, and Chynna Phillips, the daughters, respectively, of Brian Wilson of The Beach Boys and of John and Michelle Phillips of The Mamas & the Papas. (If the video doesn’t play for some reason, you can hear the version here)

 

CONTENDER #2: Gretchen Wilson

Gretchen Frances Wilson (born June 26, 1973) is an American country music artist. She made her debut in 2004 with the Grammy Award-winning single “Redneck Woman,” a number-one hit on the Billboard country charts. She covered the song for the 2013 album “Under the Covers“.

 

TIME TO VOTE! Which version do you like better and why? When you’re done voting, please visit these other BOTB participants and check out their cool battles:

Thanks for your participation and your votes! I’ll be back next month, on July 15th, for another battle. Until then, rock on…

Advertisements

19 thoughts on “Battle of the Bands: Doctor My Eyes by Jackson Browne

  1. MICHELE, this is a terrific song — my second favorite Jackson Browne song ever.

    WILSON PHILLIPS does it really well. They don’t top the hit version by the originator, but they do it justice.

    The musicians backing Gretchen are very good, unfortunately, Gretchen herself is… NOT. Oh, she’s passable, but clearly she has no real feel for the sentiment of the song — it’s “fake singing”. The track is saved by the rollicking musicianship, but Gretchen herself is simply “PERFORMING”. She’s not bad at it, but in a song that is trying to convey a deep emotional feeling, she totally fails at that.

    Vote: WILSON PHILLIPS (by another landslide).

    ~ D-FensDogG
    [Link:) Stephen T. McCarthy Reviews…

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hey Stephen,
      Your the first vote in the battle and I have a feeling that you’ve voted for the winner. I’m pretty sure Wilson Phillips is going to take this one.
      You said that Doctor My Eyes is your second favorite Jackson Browne song. What’s your favorite??

      Have a good week!

      Like

  2. Hi, Michele!

    As I make my return to active blogging I realize the extent to which music has the power to heal. An example is the use of a band to provide uplifting music that transforms a funeral into a celebration of life. In the case of “Doctor My Eyes,” a catchy melody, winning up-tempo beat and fine musicianship combine to make a sad song more palatable, even dance-worthy.

    I just came from Cathy K’s battle where she too is featuring the Wilson girls. In your battle they delighted me with their rendition of the featured song. The version by yet another Wilson girl, Gretchen, is also excellent and sounds more like the original, but Wilson Phillips put out a wonderful cover, reminiscent of Brian Wilson’s “Pet Projects” and The Honeys, and I would enjoy listening to it over and over again. It’s that good. Please give my vote to Wilson Phillips.

    Thank you, dear friend Michele!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hey Shady,
      Glad you’re coming back to active blogging! And you’re so right: music is a powerful healing tool for sure.
      Thanks for your vote. Gotcha down for Wilson Phillips.

      Like

  3. I used to be a big Jackson Browne fan before he started going to the political extreme and was filled up with causes. I’d prefer to hear his older more introspective stuff. But Browne has gone the way of so many artists. Personally, I come for the music

    Both versions you’ve presented are very well done true to the original covers. Between the two, I’m going to have to place my vote with Wilson Phillips. I like the vocal harmonies.

    Arlee Bird
    Tossing It Out

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Lee.
      Those gals sure do have some fine harmonies! Another vote for Wilson Phillips. I think they’re going to take this battle.
      Thanks for coming by.

      Like

  4. I like Jackson Browne and love this song. I loved learning about his process (I watched History of the Eagles, too, and thought it was great). I vote for Wilson Phillips. I like their sound better. Gretchen sounds as if she’s on remote control.

    Love,
    Janie

    Liked by 1 person

    • Remote control, huh? 🙂
      Another vote for Wilson Phillips. They certainly do an awesome job with this cover.
      Thanks for coming by.

      Like

  5. I always did like Jackson Browne, and I really enjoyed watching the History of the Eagles on Netflix. Every few weeks, I would try to watch a documentary on various musicians. I find their stories fascinating.

    Excellent battle. I really like Redneck Woman, but havent really followed Gretchen Wilson too much.

    Wilson Phillips, on the other hand… I have a few of their albums. Have always loved their harmonies. These girls know how to do music right!

    Please give my vote to Wilson Phillips.

    ~Mary

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Mary.
      I like that plan: watching a documentary on musicians every week! I might give that a whirl.
      I agree with what you said about the Wilson Phillips girls!
      Thanks for stopping by.

      Like

  6. Michele,

    I’m with you, I LOVE this song! I appreciated reading the factoids on the lyrics and never thought of them as being a downer. I reckon I just let the melody move me more than the words. 🙂 I can not believe you also featured the Wilson sisters in this battle! How is that we used the same girls? lol That’s just incredible. I enjoyed both covers but I definitely preferred Wilson Philips over Gretchen Wilson. I wonder if Gretchen is related to the Wilson sisters, do you know? Cool battle!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hey Cathy,
      I’m like you: I am more in tune with the music over the lyrics…of any song, really.
      And Gretchen IS related to the Wilson sisters, but not Wilson Phillips: Gretchen is related to Ann and Nancy Wilson from Heart. Powerful DNA there!
      Thanks for stopping by.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s